|
Defeat of DREAM Act Takes Hopes of Many
Sunday, November 18, 2007
Many have expressed disappointment over the defeat of the Dream (Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors) Act on October 25 by a vote of 52 to 44 -- 6 votes short to proceed to debate on the Senate floor. This bill would have allowed minors without legal immigrant status a chance at legal residency if they serve in the military for two years or graduate from school. There were many reasonable requirements in the bill: proof the applicant arrived in the United States prior to the age of 16, residency for at least 5 years, age between 12 and 30 at the time the bill is enacted, graduation from high school (or received a GED), and have no criminal record. Just how many DREAMS were extinquished by this vote? Estimates range from a low of 60,000 to "millions" by anti-immigration sites such as the Center for Immigration Studies.
Conservative Republicans opposed this measure for the same reason they voted against comprehensive immigration reform in June - they consider it a "backdoor amnesty". They point out that if an illegal alien can produce papers (potentially fraudulent ones) showing a secondary school diploma or a GED, they would immediately receive a conditional green card. This, some Republicans maintain, gives illegals a faster path to citizenship than lawfully present aliens. They also point out that by making applicants eligible for in-state tuition, this would effectively discriminate against U.S. citizens.
These concerns are further magnified by conservative anti-immigrant TV commentators such as Michelle Malkin, Sean Hannity, and Lou Dobbs who fan the voices of bigotry, ignorance, and hate in exchange for higher ratings. Their arguments typically degenerate into simplistic sterotypes that wrongly claim that illegal aliens take away jobs from Americans, are terrorists, or are criminals. Our democratic process depends on a more informed public.
Unfortunately the voices of LEGAL immigration, which we are one, have not done an effective job at communicating the basic facts: Students with access to higher education would enjoy higher earnings, use fewer federal benefits, and increase the tax base -- thus benefiting all. The fraud issues could be effectively policed just as they are today with systems already in place for high school and college graduates. And by dropping or modifying the in-state tuition benefit, the discrimination argument could be rendered moot. Although fairness is not always a consideration in our nations laws, is it fair to punish innocent children brought in to this country by the unlawful acts of their parents? Is it fair for the children of illegals who serve in the military to protect our freedoms, only to be denied a path to citizenship?
This vote shows just how difficult immigration reform may be in the coming months. It is likely that for similar legislation to pass in a future vote, it must be accompanied by a corresponding enforcement provision against illegal immigration. If so, what would that measure be?Labels: DREAM ACT, immigration, United States Association of Immigrants
posted by J. Stephen Wilson
|
|
|
Your COMPLETE Guide to the
USA Green Card Lottery is now FREE!
|
New Immigration Headlines (May 9, 2008)
|
|
![]() |
|
Green Card Lottery Announcements
Notification Letters for DV-2009 Winners BEGINS May 2008
Beware of fraudulent notification letters and fraudulent websites
Interviews for DV-2008 Winners ENDS September 30, 2008
Win the Green Card Lottery, 2008 Edition for DV-2010 is NOW available --for FREE!
Welcome to MyGreencard.com--your top information
reference for the green card (diversity visa) lottery available today, and the ONLY site that
reviews and ranks green card lottery services. Visit our Free Downloads Page for a growing library
of immigration studies, visa bulletins, and other items of interest.
Have you checked our Immigration News page lately? Each week we bring you the very latest and most relevent news items and opinions that affect YOU.
|
Now in our sixth edition, our e-book, Win the Green Card Lottery!
The COMPLETE Do-It-Yourself Guide to the USA Diversity Visa Lottery, DV-2008--DV-2010, is now available FREE
for download. For DV-2009 winners, we provide crucial tips to help avoid common
mistakes that prevent you from obtaining permanent residency. For DV-2010 entrants we include official photography and scanning instructions,
when to enter multiple entries, how to adjust status, guidelines to help select a good lottery service (if you need one) and
much more... The paperback version will soon be available at Amazon.com for $19.50.
|
|
| |
Our Visa Lottery Services Report rates green card lottery websites
by price, service and information content. This review provides fees and services comparisons, statistics, best practices for
diversity visa site owners, and more. The Executive Summary is available
FREE (without raw data, stats, and contact information). This year, we rated the
United States Association of Immigrants (myUSAi.org) the
top ranked site with a rating of 8 out of 10 points. Based on an advertising revenue model, they are the only FREE visa lottery service
site in the world. If you wish to purchase the full report for $150 USD, please contact us.
If you are interested in Selling or Purchasing an immigration related website, contact us. |
 |
|
"MyGreencard.com is the Consumer Reports of Lottery Services. Thank you!" - Niall Murphy, International Student
"I'd recommend Win the Green Card Lottery! to all my International Students. It's also a textbook for Foreign Student
Advisors." - John Diaz, International Student Advisor
"Nicely written booklet, I wish I had seen this before I threw my money away on a lottery service." - Carl Hammil, Sweden
"Thank you for giving us this chance, God bless America." - James Frimpong, Kenya
"More complete than another book costing $37!" - Anna Tai Li, Singapore
|
Order Now!
95541
|
